Flag conservation

Flag conservation
Textile conservator, Gwen Spicer of Spicer Art Conservation at work

Friday, April 19, 2013

Opening Pandora's Frame

by Gwen Spicer

Just the other day I was removing a wonderful silk embroidery from its frame. The embroidery was worked by the owner's great-great-great-great-grandmother in 1818. The embroidery had several wonderful features that make these types of textiles so individual and special. 

I have seen a fair number of embroideries and lots of methods of framing, yet I was still hardly prepared for what I found inside this one.  The first surprise was that the owner's grandmother had written in pencil on the upper back edge of the frame the name of the person who did the work in 1818. The name of the owner's great x4 grandmother was "Betsy Rosman".  This was exciting as the embroidery was not "signed" and no one knew the name of the embroiderer.  The owner had speculated that the last framing was done by his grandmother around the 1930's and that is when she wrote the name. 

As I said, I've seen many embroideries.  Textile conservators often work with family heirlooms such as embroideries or samplers, and so I have also heard many amazing stories that accompany such textiles. Sometimes a great deal is known about a particular piece, and sometimes the piece is nearly a mystery. This particular piece was a bit of both.  The owner knew some details, but as the history went back further and further, less was known (remember this piece is nearly 200 years old...that is a lot of history).  

Great care was needed to remove the numerous small nails for this particular embroidery. The silk was quite fragile near the acidic materials, and over glue was present for the attachment of the backing paper.  The browned corrugated board seen from the back was quite plain and so I was not prepared for the next surprise.  Below is the image of what I found on the reverse side of the board, which had been in direct contact with the silk since c. 1930!

backing board on embroidery, historic textiles, found behind frame, art conservation
Hidden behind a school girl's embroidery.

The board that supported this embroidery for so many years had a post mark for 1926.  It came from a box that had an earlier purpose, which was to ship 31 pounds of sweaters from New York City up the river to Hudson, New York.  Over the years I have seen many reuses of board, but for some reason, this was unexpected.  Perhaps it was the extreme nature of it.  And upon closer inspection, the board was telling another story, completely apart from the 1818 embroidery.  What is interesting is that the box was clearly used to serve a purpose at that time and that purpose was not to be a glimpse into history, as was the purpose of the embroidery.

With help from others, we found that Peckham-Foreman Inc, was a company which made knitted goods.  Among their products were swimsuits for men and women, and sweaters for men. I wondered what might these sweaters have looked like in 1926?  A quick search indicated that the fashionable "Travelo" sweater was a big seller for this company and might very well have been what was in the box.
TRAVELO 71224927
This appears to be a popular sweater, or at least we found many advertisements for this sweater. It appears to be a moderately to more expensive priced sweater at around $8.00.  Clearly with all of the pockets, this was a more complex sweater to produce.  And the wording of the advertising suggests that it is "great for yachting".

 "Travelo" an elastic knit jacket, that first appeared on the market in 1914. It was begun being manufactured in NYC in 1918 at the north east corner of Park Avenue and 130th Street.

The Travelo was sold at stores all over the United States and is one of the items listed in the center panel as  "Nationally Known Merchandise of Quality"
I wish I could read the fine print, perhaps we would learn why the woman uses a megaphone and why the man lounges in his swimsuit AND a long-sleeve sweater.

Besides the Travelo, Peckham-Foreman were also known for swimsuits - made from a blend of nylon and WOOL.

So, back to the card board backing of the box of sweaters.  I cannot help but wonder why, or even how, did it become part of this embroidery. Was the owner's grandmother associated with The Mens Shop in Hudson New York?  If yes, how?  The addressee on the package, "H.R. Deacon" appears to go on to be the City Clerk of Hudson in 1941, but no other information exists.  So many questions, and sadly very few answers.  And perhaps that is what makes this unexpected surprise so fascinating and so much fun to look into.

Gwen Spicer is a textile conservator in private practice.  Spicer Art Conservation specializes in textile conservation, object conservation, and the conservation of works on paper.  Gwen's innovative treatment and mounting of flags and textiles is unrivaled.   To contact her, please visit her website.

Friday, April 12, 2013

The conservation of Zouave uniforms

by Gwen Spicer

Much has been said about Col. Elmer Ellsworth, the first officer who achieved posthumous celebrity status after being killed in the Civil War. He is in fact considered by many to be the first fatality of the Civil War. Col. Ellsworth's uniform coat, which he wore when he was fatally shot is housed at the New York State Military Museum, and 152 years after his death, the uniform remains in good condition. But how does one conserve the coat of such an icon and ensure that it remains stable for years to come? It is a question many conservators grapple with when faced with treating a piece of history and making it stable, but not changing any part of that which makes it historically significant.

Elmer Ellsworth is perhaps the most notable New Yorker to serve in the Civil War. Born in Malta, Saratoga County, New York, he later moved to Illinois and joined a volunteer militia. It was in Chicago where Ellsworth met French military tactician Charles DeVilliers and was inspired to create his own private militia modeled after the French Zouave (pronounced "zoo-av") style that had been the standard style of the Crimean War. Ellsworth loved the Zouave style of brightly colored uniforms, pantaloons and silk sashes.

An important turn of events for Ellsworth is when he studied law in the offices of Abraham Lincoln. The two men became friends, and with the age difference he perhaps was felt to be more of a son or younger brother to Lincoln, but was held in great regard and affection by Lincoln.

Ellsworth supported Lincoln in his campaign for president and then later for troops to defend the Union.  His first attempt to recruit was in NYC, and was directed towards the fire companies. He organized the 11th New York Volunteer Infantry, known as the 1st New York Fire Zoauves, because they recruited from volunteer fire companies and wore uniforms designed to look like those of French North African Troops. These uniforms were in true Zouave style: flamboyant and unique.

zouave uniform, conservation of military uniforms and historic garments, Art Conservator
The Zouave uniform worn by Corp. Brownell of
 Troy, NY.  Brownell is often called "Ellsworth's Avenger"
Ellsworth's promising career came to an end on May 24, 1861 in Alexandria, Virginia. With a small party, including Corp. Francis Brownell of Troy, Colonel Ellsworth climbed to the roof and cut down the oversized Confederate flag flying defiantly over the Marshall House Hotel. The true events are sketchy, but the end result is that during their descent Ellsworth and his party encountered Jackson, the inn keeper, armed with a shotgun. Gunfire ensued, Jackson shot Ellsworth and Brownell avenged Ellsworth by stabbing Jackson, leaving both Jackson and the 24 year-old charismatic Ellsworth dead. 

The coat below is what Ellsworth was wearing when he was shot. His death for many marks the opening of the Civil War and Ellsworth is made famous for his heroics and his sacrifice.  His story inspires the North, and he is an instant hero.

Col. Ellsworth's gun shot wound, uniform, repair and conservation of historic textiles and military items by art conservator
Col. Ellsworth's jacket after treatment. The bullet hole is still quite prominent, what has faded significantly is the blood from his fatal wound.

The remains of the large, 14 x 24 foot, Confederate flag, now known as 
the Marshall Flag.  It is so large that it was easily seen from across the 
river, in Washington, DC where it was considered a sign of aggression.

Following his death, Col. Ellsworth became cult-like in the eyes of the Union. Poems, songs, sermons and memorial envelopes lamented his loss, and parents named their babies after him, and streets and towns used his name. 

As is clearly seen in the above image, Col. Ellsworth was shot in the chest. The bullet created a large hole that affected all of the layers in the front of his uniform. One of the brass buttons was also damaged. (His uniform is more conventional, then his Zouave designed uniforms of his troops. Only his pant legs had an extra stylish stripe.) 

It is common in textile conservation for textiles to be supported with patching or lining. The added fabric adds strength to the weakened area. But in this case, the museum clearly did not want the hole to be patched. They wanted the area to still show the hole due to its historic significance, while also being stable. Smaller holes that have occurred due to time, insects, and/or perhaps less careful handling, were stabilized locally with patching. But the hole left from the gunshot was not patched, rather the surrounding edges of each layer were individually secured with stitches in order to prevent continued, or future fraying. Fabrics which are used for patching are a wide range of fabrics and weave structures, mostly selected to blend with the artifact. 

Handling of artifacts has changed greatly from above, where in 1961, a well-meaning historian models Ellsworth's jacket for a newspaper photographer. The uniform coat of Col. Ellsworth remains part of the collection of Civil War items in the New York State Military History Museum, along with most of the enormous Confederate flag that Ellsworth took down at the site. Following his White House funeral, Ellsworth’s body laid in state at City Hall in New York City and at the State Capitol in Albany, respectively, before being buried in Mechanicville. The Marshall House flag accompanied Ellsworth’s body home to New York state. Relics connected to Ellsworth’s death became prized possessions, including pieces cut, or “souvenired,” from the Marshall House flag (hence the condition of the flag in the above photograph).  

The image above is a bit grainy, (The image is a double image) This is a photograph from an exhibit of items associated with Ellsworth (c. 1865). The large stripped item in the front is most probably the Marshall Flag. Visible in the center is Ellsworth's uniform. 

An unbelievable amount of information is available about Ellsworth. Some great places to visit are the websites for the Smithsonian as well as the NYS Military Museum.

Gwen Spicer is a textile conservator in private practice.  Spicer Art Conservation specializes in textile conservation, object conservation, and the conservation of works on paper.  Gwen's innovative treatment and mounting of flags and textiles is unrivaled.   To contact her, please visit her website.